Public ledger

Every completed review

Append-only and public. Each entry names the reviewer, the version they read, their scores and verdict, and any conflict they declared. Each digest covers the entry before it, so no past review can be changed quietly.

Entries
12
Verdicts
7 accept · 4 request changes · 0 reject · 1 comment
Head digest
602d13a91dfebb6d

Entries

ReviewProofStageReviewerVerdictScoreConflictsDigest
RV-2026-0104
2026-10-10
AI-PRF-0047
read v1.0.0
CommunityT. AdityaAccept13/15None declared← e2fff3a122ade1ef
602d13a91dfebb6d
RV-2026-0101
2026-10-07
AI-PRF-0049
read v1.1.0
CommunityY. HakimAccept14/15None declared← 6176384024425e97
2f3e6fc9c01eb575
RV-2026-0097
2026-09-22
AI-PRF-0044
read v0.9.0
PublicP. WidodoAccept12/15None declared← a44bb942334fe18a
70c92266b0d02c56
RV-2026-0090
2026-09-04
AI-PRF-0042
read v1.0.0
CommunityB. SiregarAccept13/15None declared← 02093422beb28003
a44bb942334fe18a
RV-2026-0088
2026-09-01
AI-PRF-0042
read v1.0.0
CommunityY. HakimAccept13/15None declared← ab701e1613d6c8ea
9f967e7c0a73c5f9
RV-2026-0083
2026-08-22
AI-PRF-0038
read v1.0.2
CommunityR. SetiawanAccept12/15None declared← 853e47099f462850
8c257e1b84c99d3a
RV-2026-0081
2026-08-15
AI-PRF-0042
read v1.0.0
InstituteEditorial BoardAccept12/15None declared← 0000000000000000
853e47099f462850

Audit it yourself

Recompute the chain

Start from the genesis value, join each entry’s fields with |, hash with SHA-256 and keep the first 16 hex characters. Each result must match the digest shown, and the last one must match the head digest above.

digest(n) = sha256(
  digest(n-1) | id | proof | version | stage |
  reviewer | verdict | score | filed | conflicts
)[0:16]

digest(0) = 0000000000000000

# first entry
0000000000000000|RV-2026-0081|AI-PRF-0042|v1.0.0|internal|Editorial Board|accept|12|2026-08-15|None declared
→ 853e47099f462850
  • Amend, never edit

    A correction is a new entry that names the one it amends. Both stay, and the chain keeps growing.

  • Published as data

    The full ledger will be downloadable as CSV and JSON, so anyone can rerun the check outside this site.